Telehealth's early bonanza during the pandemic has given way to persistently elevated use in primary care, a Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) report showed.
Analysis of Medicare fee-for-service (FFS) data showed an increase in Medicare primary care visits from 0.1% of all primary care in February to , representing an increase from about 2,000 to 1.28 million telehealth visits per week.
Meanwhile, there was a "precipitous" drop in in-person visits for primary care in mid-March as COVID-19 took hold in the U.S., then a rise from mid-April through May, according to the report from the Office of the Assistant Secretary for Planning and Evaluation.
Use of telehealth in primary care "declined somewhat but appears to have leveled off at a persistent and significant level by the beginning of June," the report noted. It still accounted for 22.7% of Medicare beneficiaries' primary care visits as of June 3rd.
Overall, weekly primary care visit rates have not yet returned to pre-pandemic levels.
"Based on early experience with Medicare primary care telehealth at the start of the COVID-19 public health emergency, there is evidence that Medicare's new telehealth flexibilities played a critical role in helping to maintain access to primary health care services -- when many beneficiaries and providers were concerned with transmission of COVID-19," the authors noted. "The stable and sustained use of telehealth after in-person primary care visits started to resume in mid-April suggests there may be continued demand for telehealth in Medicare, even after the pandemic ends."
The findings overall match those from healthcare provider databases suggesting a 60% to 70% drop in health care office visits, partially offset by telehealth visits, with the start of the pandemic. Drug market research firm IQVIA has reported from physician surveys that about 9% of patient interactions were via telehealth prior to the pandemic but 51% during the shutdown, with expectation of a 21% rate after the pandemic, the HHS report noted.
There have been calls for Medicare to make the loosened rules around telemedicine permanent, and some legislative movement in that direction, but private insurers have signaled the opposite.
Fred Pelzman, MD, an internal medicine physician at Weill Cornell Medicine in New York City (and 51˶ columnist), said an informal survey of his patients indicated they would be willing to do up to 50% of their care via video tools.
"We went from a handful of video visits in our practice to several thousand over the course of the months," he said. "It's a great way to take care of people, kept a lot of people safe, we think. What has happened is that as we started to open our practice back up again and offer appointments, the floodgates have opened and patients are declining video visits."
Those patients opting for in-person visits tend to be older, braving what feels like a quiet time in the pandemic for the state to take care of necessary visits, he noted. "I think ultimately that we'll plateau. It will probably come down a little more."
The study included Medicare FFS Part B claims from January through May 2020 for primary care services along with preliminary Medicare Part B primary care claims data up to June 3. Primary care services included evaluation and management, preventive services, and advance care planning.
Telehealth usage increased most in urban counties early in the pandemic and saw smaller declines in May compared with rural counties across the country. Among cities, Boston had the greatest proportion of primary care visits by telehealth (73.1%) and Phoenix the lowest (37%).
Notably, the rate "was not strongly associated with differences in COVID-19 severity across cities as measured by rate of hospitalizations per thousand Medicare FFS beneficiaries," the report pointed out.
Primary Source
Office of the Assistant Secretary for Planning and Evaluation Brief
Bosworth A, et al "Medicare Beneficiary Use of Telehealth Visits: Early Data from the Start of COVID-19 Pandemic" Washington, DC: Office of the Assistant Secretary for Planning and Evaluation, U.S. Department of Health and Human Services. July 28, 2020.